Whatās wrong with praising Hitler?
Thatās a question most of us never expected to have to answer, and a question I never expected I would type. But when a former American president publicly dined with Holocaust deniers and Hitler aficionados, the current president of the United States chose to try and answer that question.
āHitler is a demonic figure,ā Joe Biden tweeted, after making it clear that yes ā the Holocaust happened.
The word ādemonicā felt a bit off to some scholars and translators.
āIt doesnāt make me uneasy; but it doesnāt feel right, either,ā said Larry Rosenwald, professor emeritus at Wellesley College, and an active Yiddishist. āCalling people demonic means classifying them as non-human, which implies that human beings are incapable of the things Hitler yemach shāmo (āmay his name be blotted outā) or others have committed.Ā And of course human beings are not at all incapable of them.ā
Rosenwald likened the phrase to saying āthis is not what America isā when, he added, āitās exactly what America is, with its traditions of lynching and expulsion.ā
āDemons are demons, people are people. When Bashevis writes about demons,ā said Rosenwald, referencing the work of Isaac Bashevis Singer, ātheyāre a different species; they insinuate themselves into mirrors to entrap self-indulgent women.ā
āThe corrosion of political discourseā
But first things first ā word choice aside, and however ādemonā may sound to all the good souls who are reading I.B. Singer, itās a very good thing to have a president who is anti-Hitler. You would think that would be a basic requirement of every American politician, but these days, it is not.
As the PBS NewsHour soberly detailed, its correspondents called every Republican senator and five other prominent Republicans, and only a few would condemn Trumpās choice to host a dinner at Mar-a-Lago with known neo-Nazi, Holocaust denier and white supremacist Nick Fuentes, and Ye, the musician formerly known as Kanye West, who has made his antisemitic views and admiration of Hitler very public.
āItās reprehensible. If a Republican is in leadership, they should have been out there within hours of finding out about this dinner,ā Washington Post columnist Jonathan Capehart said on the NewsHour. āThis is whatās leading to the corrosion of political discourse. And, in our society, we have people who are openly, openly antisemitic, and no consequences. Thatās outrageous.ā
Capehartās comments were made on Shabbat, so many observant Jews missed them; I was grateful to have heard them after Shabbat ended.
Letās not take a prominent columnistās decency, or a presidentās decency, for granted, especially with the memory of āvery fine people on both sidesā still fresh in our minds. Biden has said that the Charlottesville march of torch-bearing men, which included the yelling āJews will not replace us,ā is what motivated him to run for president. And Biden, who has repeatedly said that his concern is for the soul of America, is absolutely right to explicitly call out the āsilenceā of prominent people who refuse to say that Hitler was a mass murderer.
But letās get back to demons.
āItās more likely to see Hitler associated with Hamanā
Itās interesting to note that in Yiddish, the mother tongue of many victims of the Holocaust, a demon may not exactly be what a demon is in English.
āSheyd ā ghost or demon or spirit or āmazikā evildoer ā does not necessarily imply evil, though it can be a trickster figure, responsible for temptation ā or it could possess a human body and cause confusion, distress and physical ailments,ā said Jessica Kirzane, editor-in-chief of In geveb: A Journal of Yiddish Studies, and a professor of Yiddish at The University of Chicago.
āTayvl ā linguistically related to the English word devil ā does have more of this kind of association. And you can say ātsum tayvlā āĀ āgo to the devilāĀ ā to mean an equivalent of āgo to hell,ā but I would still not associate the word with Hitler,ā Kirzane said.
Staying with the devil theme for a moment, āthere are some associations between evil and especially tayvl, and European/Christian literatures about devils generally are translated into this world, creating further associations with a more Christian conception of good and evil,ā Kirzane said.
āStill,ā she added, āit seems more likely to see Hitler associated with Haman, or with Amalek ā that is to say, evil human actors.ā
āI was not acquainted with hellā
Whether Hitler is portrayed as Haman or a demon or anyone else, scholars noted that using any metaphor when discussing the Holocaust can be tricky.
āWhy are metaphors tricky? Imre KertĆ©sz explained the issue brilliantly in his Holocaust novelĀ Fatelessness,ā said Samuel Spinner, an assistant professor at Johns Hopkins and the author of Jewish Primitivism. āThe novel is, to a degree, entirely about the question of the role of metaphor in communicating the experience and history of the Holocaust. The last few pages are directly about it.
Imre Kertesz at the 2005 Berlin Film Festival. Photo by Getty Images
āThe novelās protagonist, newly arrived home in Budapest after surviving Auschwitz, meets a journalist who wants to hear from him about āthe hell of the camps,āā Spinner continued. āKertĆ©sz narrates his protagonistās thoughts in response: āI had nothing at all to say about that as I was not acquainted with hell and couldnāt even imagine what that was like.āā
Spinner said he found himself thinking of KertĆ©szās concern with āhow to narrate the Holocaust without rhetorical inflationā while reading the online discussion on Bidenās language.
āSome of the replies I saw on Twitter said that ādemonicāĀ ā and by extension any metaphor ā just means what it means,ā Spinner said. āKertĆ©sz deals with this objection too, writing that the journalist assured the protagonist that āit was just a manner of speaking.’ā
The journalist in KertĆ©szās story then asks: āCan we imagine a concentration camp as anything but a hell?ā The protagonist replies that āeveryone could think what they liked about it, but as far as I was concerned I could only imagine a concentration camp, since I was somewhat acquainted with what that was, but not hell.ā
āThis subtly diminishes the personal responsibilityā
Spinner pointed out that an image of Hitler as a kind of demon appeared on the cover of a story by the famed Yiddish writer Der Nister, published in New York in 1943.
Interestingly, in the past, Jewish publications have used ādemonā to describe Hitler. A February 1954 Commentary headline read: āThe wretched little demon that was Hitler: What Possessed the Soul of the Third Reich.ā
Hitler appeared as a kind of demon on the cover of a story by the famed Yiddish writer Der Nister in 1943. Courtesy of Samuel Spinner
In 1987, The New York Times ran a letter to the editor with the headline āHitler and the Demonic,ā in response to a William Safire column. The letter writer, Gail Horsman Rivera of Brooklyn, did not like the supernatural framing of Hitler that she felt Safire employed. Like todayās scholars commenting on Bidenās use of ādemonic,ā Rivera felt this framing placed Hitler outside of the realm of human nature.
Safireās article on a joint communiquĆ© issued by Roman Catholic and Jewish leaders ācontained some astute observations,ā Rivera wrote. āHowever, I am not as pleased as he to see the word ādemonicā used to describe Nazi ideology. This subtly diminishes the personal responsibility of Hitler and his followers in formulating and perpetrating their crimes. It implies that their deeds were supernaturally evil. They were extraordinarily evil, but the history of our planet has shown again and again that this kind of depravity is well within the bounds of human nature. It is all too easily repeated without any help from supernature.ā
Some scholars have said that describing Hitler as a demon removes the spotlight of guilt from his millions of followers ā without whom the Holocaust would not have happened.
In āMan, Demon, Icon: Hitlerās Image between Cinematic Representation and Historical Reality,ā scholar Michael Elm writes: āAlthough historians have emphasized Hitlerās decisive role in the Holocaust, it is nevertheless somewhat misleading to portray him as a demon.
āIndeed, although Hitler himself was unquestionably wicked, the bureaucratic organization and efficient implementation of the Final Solution cannot be perceived as the act of a single person. Viewing it as such risks overlooking the role played by the many knowledgeable German citizens who actively assisted with or took advantage of the deportations and murder.ā
āThe same demon that lived in Babylonā
When I heard the word ādemonic,ā I immediately thought of the extreme Biblical commentaries I have encountered which explain too much through the idea that a demon, or alternately, Satan, is behind everything.
Consider this RealFaith.com commentary on Daniel 3:8-15 by Pastor Mark Driscoll titled āSame Demon, Different Hitlerā:
āWhen you see the exact same evil thing happening at various points in history, often it is because the same demonic spirit is at work behind the scenes,ā Driscoll writes. āSome things never change. The same demon that lived in Babylon with Nebuchadnezzar later moved to Germany with Hitler.ā
This idea that Nazi horrors can be explained by a ādemonā who flies through the centuries is, I think, part of what made scholars queasy when they read Bidenās tweet. But I doubt that the RealFaith.com perspective is what Biden drew on; instead, I think he leaned on something far more personal ā his own fatherās view of the Holocaust.
The anger of Joe Bidenās father
In 2015, I heard Joe Biden speak at the Reform Jewish Biennial in Florida. He was on a goodbye tour, and he thanked the Reform Jewish community for its support of gay marriage, when it was the only religious group that did so. He said he was sure that the Reform movementās support for trans rights would also come to be viewed as the just thing to do.
The main part of his speech was about his fatherās horror, expressed at the dinner table, over the mass murder of the Holocaust, and how, in memory of his father, he took each of his children on a father-child trip to Dachau when they became teenagers.
Then-Vice President Joe Biden and his wife Jill Biden at a 2011 White House Hanukkah reception. Photo by Getty Images
I cried as I listened to Biden describe taking his teenage daughter to Dachau and talking about how that trip alone with their father had changed each one of his children. As I read online discussion swirling about ādemonic,ā I thought of how this is a president who takes his children to a concentration camp to honor his fatherās memory and moral vision.
I could hear Bidenās fatherās anger in ādemonic.ā
What is potentially ādemonicā is the continued willingness of some American voters to believe in lies ā and anoint leaders who anoint lies. I hear the fear of that willingness in Bidenās word choice, too.
Ā
Related
The post Why we should think twice before we call Hitler a ādemonā appeared first on The Forward.
