
Q:Ā Did the FBI wait until after the 2016 election to review the Hillary Clinton emails found on Anthony Weinerās laptop?
A: No. A viral story misinterprets an FBI document and ignores widely reported facts.
FULL ANSWER
Citing a recently released FBI document, a viral storyĀ misleads readers by claiming that the emails of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton that were found on Anthony Weinerās laptop werenāt āreviewedā by an FBI investigator until after the 2016 election.
The FB News Cycle story claims that the document proves that now-fired FBI agent Peter Strzok āburied evidence of HRCās corruption.ā
But the premise is false: The emails were reviewed daysĀ before the election.
Some background:
- On July 5, 2016, former FBI Director James ComeyĀ announcedĀ that the bureau would recommend that charges not be filed in the probe into Clintonās use of a private email system while heading the State Department.
- On Sept. 26, 2016, the FBI executed a search warrant on former Rep. AnthonyĀ Weinerās iPhone, iPad and laptop computer, and discovered 141,000Ā emails on the laptop that were potentially relevant to the FBIās closedĀ investigation of Clinton. Longtime Clinton aide Huma Abedin was married to Weiner at the time. (Abedinās lawyer said early this year the couple was privately finalizing their divorce.) Weiner was being separatelyĀ investigated forĀ āsextingā with an underage teenage girl.
- A month later, on Oct. 28, 2016, Comey told lawmakers in a letter that the FBI had ālearned of the existence of emails that appear to be pertinent to the investigationā and that investigators would āreview these emails to determine whether they contain classified information.ā
- On Nov. 6, 2016, Comey told Congress in a follow-up memo that the FBI had āreviewed all of the communications that were to or from Hillary Clinton while she was Secretary of Stateā and that officials āhave not changed our conclusions.ā
- The election took place Nov. 8, 2016.
The Aug. 4 storyĀ on fbnewscycle.com ignores these facts and claims that the emails found on Weinerās laptop werenāt eyed until after the election. The post gained popularity on the Facebook page āDonald Trump is Our President,ā from which it was reshared by thousands.
āWhile the NYPD was conducting a forensic analysis of the Weiner/Abedin laptop, it was discovered that the hard drive contained 350,000 of Hillary Clintonās emails and 344,000 Blackberry communications,ā the story says. āHereās what you were never told by the HRC-BHO protective media.Ā These were never reviewed by the FBI investigators assigned to help lead agent Peter Strzok. Nor, was any attempt made to analyze the newly discovered files until after the election was over.ā
As evidence, the website includes an FBI document dated Nov. 9, 2016 ā the day after the election ā that indicates StrzokĀ had requested that a copy of a laptopās hard drive be reviewed for āevidence of intrusion.ā The document was among a batchĀ releasedĀ earlier this month to the conservative group Judicial Watch.
But that document isnāt evidence that the emails werenāt reviewed before the Nov. 8 election.
A June 2018Ā reportĀ by the Justice Department Office of the Inspector General, which conducted a review of the bureauās investigation, indicates that the FBI obtained a search warrant for the laptop on Oct. 30, 2016 ā this time to look for information related to the Clinton email investigation ā and that multiple investigators were involved in the review.
āThe Midyear team flagged all potentially work-related emails encountered during the review process and compared those to emails that they had previously reviewed in other datasets,ā the report states, referring to the investigation by its āMidyearā code name. āAny work-related emails that were unique, meaning that they did not appear in any other dataset, were individually reviewed by the Lead Analyst, Strzok, and FBI Attorney 1 for evidentiary value.ā
The report indicates the review of the emails was completed Nov. 6, 2016, before Comey sent his second letter to Congress. Still, it says, the lead analyst on the case told the inspector generalās office that even after that review, the FBI needed to do more investigative work.
āThe Lead Analyst told us that the further investigative steps needed to complete the investigation included at least a āmalware analysisā to examine the laptop for intrusion and a re-interview of Abedin,ā the report states.
The analyst said that such an analysis was needed to know if the laptop was ācompromised by anyoneā or if a āforeign power obtainedā classified material.
So, while further examination took place after the election, itās false to claim, as fbnewscycle.com did, that Strzokās intrusion analysis request āshows he sat on the laptop for more than 6 weeks ā until the election was over!ā
The FBIās handling of the emails on Weinerās laptop has indeed fueledĀ criticismĀ about why the agency chose to wait weeks before taking action on the late-September discovery. The inspector generalās report said it found no āconsistent or persuasive explanationā for the delay, but said it gathered no evidence that the laptop was ādeliberately placed on the back-burner by others in the FBI to protect Clinton.ā
Clinton, for her part, has argued that the timing of the announcement to review the emails did quite the opposite.
Editorās note: FactCheck.org is one of several organizationsĀ working with FacebookĀ to debunk false stories shared on the social media network.
Sources
āA Review of Various Actions by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and Department of Justice in Advance of the 2016 Election.ā Office of the Inspector General, U.S. Department of Justice. June 2018.
Comey, James. Director, FBI. Letter to Congress. 28 Oct 2016.
Comey, James. Director, FBI. Letter to Congress. 6 Nov 2016.
āStatement by FBI Director James B. Comey on the Investigation of Secretary Hillary Clintonās Use of a Personal E-Mail System.ā Press release, FBI. 5 Jul 2016.
Strzok, Peter. Agent, FBI. āCase Support Request.ā 9 Nov 2016.
